Women of Washington

Communicating America’s Founding Principles

Women of Washington is an educational organization with a focus on understanding local, national, and global issues that are critical to our world today.

The Great Ice Melt Myth - Myth 6

By Jay Lehr and Tom Harris 

Myth: Global Warming is causing all of the ice on Earth to melt, inducing a catastrophic rise in sea levels that will wipe out  our coastal civilizations and cause ecological disasters such as the extinction of the polar bears. 

Reality: The most dramatic images used to support the global warming movement involve the constant barrage of videos showing sheets of ice calving (breaking) off of melting glaciers.  These images are always accompanied by voice-overs warning that the Earth is doomed if we humans continue to burn fossil fuels.  Al Gore  predicted in 2008 that by 2013, skyrocketing temperatures would eliminate all ice in the Arctic. He also predicted that because of massive melting of the polar ice pack (floating sea ice) sea levels would rise 20 feet or more wiping out coastal cities. Dramatic images in his movie An Inconvenient Truth show New York City being inundated by a massive tidal wave caused by global warming. Let us show you how crazy this is. 

According to the National Snow and Ice Data Center (nsidc.org), ice currently covers 6 million square miles, or one tenth the Land area on Earth, about the area of South America. Floating ice or Sea Ice alternately called Pack Ice at the North and South Poles covers 6% of the ocean’s surface (nsidc.org), an area similar to North America. The most important measure of ice is its thickness. The United States Geologic Survey estimates the total ice on Earth weighs 28 million Gigatons(a billion tons).  Antarctica and Greenland combined represent 99% of all ice on Earth. The remaining one per cent is in glaciers, ice sheets and sea ice. Antarctica can exceed 3 miles in thickness and Greenland one mile. If they were to melt sea level would indeed rise over 200 feet, but not even the most radical alarmists suggest that possibility arising due to the use of fossil fuels. However the ice that flows off of the Antarctic and Greenland called shelf ice represents only half a percent of all the Earth’s ice and which if melted would raise sea level only 14 inches, (nsidc.com). 

Although Sea Ice covers 6% of the entire oceans at an average thickness of 6 feet, were it all to melt sea level would rise only 4 inches. If we melted all 200,000 of the Earth’s temperate zone glaciers sea level would rise another two feet. So total catastrophe can only occur if we can melt the Antarctic and Greenland.  But the Antarctic is the coldest place on Earth. At www.coolantarctica.com calculations show the temperature would have to rise 54 degrees Fahrenheit to start the warming of that Ice Cap. 

The geologic record provides a perspective on how climate impacts the quantity of ice on Earth. They have encompassed every extreme. 800 million years ago the planet was almost entirely encased in ice (Rafferty, J.P. Cryogenics Period). Since then there have been many extended periods when there has been no ice present. As recently as 3 million years ago sea levels are believed to have been 165 feet higher than today. While ice covered a third of the entire planet during the last ice age, when sea levels were 400 feet lower, allowing ancient peoples to cross the Siberian Land Bridge to  populate North America. 

Al Gore predicted in 2007 that by 2013 the Arctic Ocean would be completely ice free. In the summer of 2012 ice levels did reach all time lows in the Arctic.  Emboldened by this report Australian Professor Chris Turney launched an expedition in December of 2013 to prove that the Antarctic Sea Ice was also undergoing catastrophic melting only to have his ship trapped in sea ice such that it could not even be rescued by modern ice-breakers. 

The Professor should have known that a more accurate estimate of sea ice can be had from satellite images taken every day at the Poles since 1981. These images show that between summer and winter, regardless of the degree of summer melting, the sea ice completely recovers to its original size the winter before for almost every year since the pictures were taken.  The sea ice has been stubbornly resistant to Al Gore’s predictions. In fact the average annual coverage of sea ice has been essentially the same since satellite observations began in 1981. However that has not stopped global warming advocates and even government agencies from cherry picking the data to mislead the public. 

Africa’s Mt. Kilimanjaro has been the poster child for land based melting supposed to be caused by Global Warming.  It did loose half of its ice cover between 1880 and 1936 before the major use of fossil fuels and only 30% more in the past 80 years. However the temperature at its peak has not risen at any time during these years above freezing (32 degrees Fahrenheit). The melting has been due to deforestation and the dry air rising to the mountain top causing the ice to turn directly into water vapor a process called sublimation. 

Melting glaciers are another topic of the warming alarmists.  Indeed they can choose to point to some that are actually melting, ignoring those that are growing or remaining stable.  Why the differences?  They are largely dependent on whether over periods of time more snow falls than ice melts or the reverse.  They are a great place to cherry pick data. 

The Antarctic and Greenland icecaps are not melting. The total percentage of the Earth’s ice that has melted the past 100 years as we exited the last Little Ice Age that froze Washington‘s troops at Valley Forge is estimated to be .16%. Humanity can relax, coastal cities and wildlife are not going to be wiped out as a result of sea level rise.  Fossil fuel combustion has had no impact on the minor sea level rise of a few inches we are experiencing every century. 

Portions of this article have been excerpted with permission of the publisher and author of the 2018 book THE MYTHOLOGY OF GLOBAL WARMNG by Bruce Bunker Ph.D..Publisher: Moonshine Cove/ For more information on this topic, the authors strongly recommend this book as the very best source of accurate information on the climate change debate.